“You can’t overpay for the house because you’re going to get an appraisal.”
Is it accurate, as some mortgage loan officers and real estate agents claim to tell their clients?
It is true that your lender will employ an appraiser to determine the house’s value when you purchase one.
It’s also true that these evaluations shield prospective homeowners from overpaying for properties.
It is untrue that these evaluations keep purchasers from paying too much.
These lenders don’t want to protect home buyers from having to pay a few percentage points too much for their homes because their appraisals typically run about 4% too high, according to one study.
- Fair market value isn’t just one dollar amount; it’s a range. This means that the contract price must be clearly above the ambiguous fair market value range before an appraisal can be deemed low.
- You shouldn’t rely on the lender’s appraisal to keep you from overpaying for a property. It is likely to keep you from overpaying by a significant margin, but it is unlikely to shield you from overpaying by a small percentage point. Do all your price research before negotiating price.
- Make sure you inform your appraiser of the value at which your PMI would stop if you’re having an appraisal done in an attempt to have the monthly Private Mortgage Insurance (PMI) fee removed from your mortgage payment. It might not matter to your appraiser and it might not have any bearing, but it might Because market value is a range of prices rather than a single price, appraisers have some latitude.
Your lender will order what is known as a lender’s appraisal, which is an estimate of the value of the home you plan to purchase (or a bank appraisal)
Given that lenders charge their clients, the home buyers, for their appraisals, that name might be a little unclear to them.
Although they don’t, home buyers may believe that because they paid for these appraisals, they belong to them. They are the lenders’ property and are meant to safeguard them.
Does Knowing the Contract Price Change the Appraised Value?
It’s long been known that lenders appraisals, that is, appraisals ordered by lenders to check on the value of homes, are usually at, or above, the price in the contract.
There were those who harbored suspicions that appraisers were merely validating the contract price to appease their clients, the lenders.
Savings and Loan Era
Back in the day, when Savings Duh!.
But for the past thirty years or so, things have been different today.
Previously, S The mortgage payment was sent by the homeowner each month to the S
S In this example, the S&Ls made 1%.
When S
Of course, in that case, buyers are far more likely to stop making mortgage payments. The S
Mortgage Brokers and Mortgage Bankers
Today is different. Presently, S
When completing all the paperwork for your mortgage, you typically work with a mortgage broker. However, after the sale closes and you become the owner of the home, your mortgage is owned by someone else, such as Fannie Mae, not your mortgage broker. Following the completion of the mortgage loan documentation and the home sale, your mortgage broker is paid right away.
In essence, Fannie Mae tells mortgage brokers, “We’ll buy your loans from you if you make them that meet our criteria.” ”.
The mortgage broker doesn’t care as much if the homeowner later experiences a foreclosure because they have already been paid for the handoff of the mortgage to Fannie Mae, or whoever. Whoever owns the mortgage at the time of the foreclosure would primarily be at fault.
It is now reasonable to take actions that wouldn’t be reasonable under the previous SBA because the “making of mortgage loans” and “owning of mortgage loans” are separated.
It has long been suspected that appraisers and mortgage brokers understood, either explicitly or implicitly, that appraisals shouldn’t be lower than the contract price unless the contract price was absurdly high.
Mortgage brokers don’t like low appraisals because they’re more work. A few deals will also be killed by low appraisals, in which case the mortgage broker’s entire effort in obtaining the loan will have been in vain.
Studies were done in the past to look at “appraisal bias” or “confirmation bias.” That is, whether appraisals were biased toward confirming the contract price so the mortgage loans can close and the mortgage brokers can get paid.
But those past studies had to estimate the value of homes and compare their mathematical estimates of home values to the appraisers’ estimates of home values.
This study we’re discussing here was a huge improvement because it didn’t have to estimate the value of homes using some math algorithm, they had 2 appraisals done within 6 months of each other on 8,533 houses. They were only comparing how the appraised values changed for the same homes.
Appraised Values – Before and After
From 2012 to 2015, Fannie Mae acquired ownership of 8,533 homes following foreclosure.
Once Fannie took ownership of those houses, they had each one appraised before determining list prices and putting the houses on the market.
All 8,533 of these homes later received another appraisal—the lender’s appraisal—after they were put under contract with buyers, and this time the appraisers were aware of the contract prices. That is, the appraisers were aware of the price that was already specified in the written contracts between the sellers and the buyers this time.
The distribution of the appraised values is displayed in the first graphic below along with the projected future contract prices (red line).
The appraisals for the identical 8,533 houses are displayed in the second graphic, but in these assessments, the appraisers were aware of the price that the buyer and seller had previously agreed upon in their contract.
The second appraisals, which are the lenders’ appraisals, show a significant shift.
Looking at the exact same 8,533 homes.
- The appraiser only received 45% of the appraisals at or above the (future) contract price when they didn’t know the future contract price.
- However, 2093% of the appraisals were received at or above the contract price once the appraiser was aware of it.
Click graphic to enlarge
The study finds that the second appraisals—the lenders’ appraisals—were 4 after accounting for the possibility that home prices increased between the time of the first and the second appraisal. 2% more expensive on average than the initial appraisals for the same homes
How Appraisals Are Done
This is a brief and unpolished description of how appraisals are carried out.
Select Comps. An appraiser will search for comparable homes that have recently sold in order to determine the worth of a property. These homes are called comps, or comparables.
Adjustments. The appraiser will need to “adjust” the comps’ values in order to make them more comparable to the house under contract because the comps won’t be exact matches.
The appraiser will reduce the comp’s value to make it more comparable to the home under contract if it is larger or otherwise superior to the home under contract. “If the comparable property had the same square footage as the house under contract, what would its value be?” or anything similar
The appraiser will increase the comp’s value if it is worse than the house under contract. “If the comp had the same ____ as the home under contract, what would its value be?”
After making adjustments to all the comparables, appraisers are able to estimate the value of the house under contract.
Weighting (reconciliation). Some comps, however, may be a lot better than others. Assume one example was built by the same builder, in the same subdivision, with the same model and floorplan, and it sold just one month ago. The appraiser can give it more weight because that is a great comparison.
Assuming three comparables in the appraisal, rather than assigning a weight of 33 to each 33%, the appraiser could assign a higher weight to that outstanding comp and reduce the weights assigned to the other two comps.
Just so you know, during this weighting phase, appraisers typically arrive at or surpass the contract price in their assessments. They frequently give more weight to more expensive comparables, which increases the home’s appraised value.
My friend who works as a mortgage loan officer often tells his clients, “You can’t overpay for the house.” You’re going to get an appraisal. ”.
Knowing that eases his clients’ anxiety a little and gives them more confidence to submit written offers to purchase homes.
The mortgage company will then order an appraisal to ensure that they aren’t lending the buyer more money than the house is worth after the buyer and seller reach a written agreement on price and terms.
similar to the S
Mortgage Fraud. Indeed, during the real estate boom, there was a particular kind of fraud that focused on exactly that. The seller would arrange for a straw buyer to purchase their home for an excessive amount of money, and once they acquired it, the straw buyer would never pay their mortgage. It was a way to defraud mortgage companies. Appraisers had to be involved in the transaction for sellers for that type of fraud to succeed. It’s very uncommon since that fraud cannot function without dishonest appraisers.
Lender Guidelines. Verifying that your loan qualifies for your interest rate is a much more common use for appraisals than mortgage fraud.
Interest rates are frequently correlated with down payment size, and the size of the down payment required to qualify for a lower interest rate is correlated with home value.
Let’s say, for example, that you intend to borrow the remaining 80% and make a down payment equal to 2020% of the house’s value. In the event that you made only a down payment for 2019%, your interest rate and monthly payments would probably increase. %20(And%20if%20you%20put%20less%20down,%20you%20must%20pay%20expensive%20mortgage%20insurance%20every%20month.) ).
- Your interest rate (and/or associated costs) will probably go up if your down payment is less than 20% of the total amount due.
- Increase the amount if your down payment is less than 10% of the total amount due.
- if your down payment is less than 5%, increase it even more, and
- If your credit score is lower than a 3, your mortgage company most likely won’t lend you any money at all. 5% down payment.
The appraised value is utilized by your lender, for instance, to determine the amount of the down payment required to hit 2020%, 2010%, 5%, or 203 5%, or the location of the breakpoints that cause your mortgage’s interest rate to fluctuate
Your lender will base those computations on the contract price if it is less than the appraised value. Your lender will use the lower of the appraised value and the contract price to determine those percentages.
Low Appraisals are Surprisingly Uncommon
Approximately 2092 percent of the time, the appraisal has no effect on the mortgage loan because the appraised value is equal to or greater than the contract price.
But about 8% of the time, the appraised value of the house is LESS than the price the buyer and seller agreed to in the written contract and that can increase the interest rate in the buyer’s loan. It could also make it so the buyer can’t qualify for a mortgage at all.
First of all, you should definitely renegotiate the price with the seller if the appraisal is low.
In fact, the price is negotiated down approximately half the time when an appraisal results in a low estimate.
The buyer may be able to negotiate the price down to the appraised value entirely at times, or just partially. In any case, when an appraisal is less than what was agreed upon in the contract, the seller is usually persuaded to accept a lower offer, and the sale closes at that reduced amount.
Additionally, in this specific study, the likelihood that the contract would not close (within 90 days) increased by nearly 10 percentage points when the appraisal was low. In those circumstances, the buyers most likely canceled the majority of the contracts.
Careful. This all depends on how the original contract was written. If there was a financing or appraisal contingency clause in the original contract, the buyer will probably be able to cancel it if the appraisal is low. If the buyer can back out of the agreement if the appraisal is low, that gives the buyer leverage over the seller to lower the asking price.
Let’s say the contract price is $200,000. In addition to having $40,000 for a down payment, the buyer intends to borrow $160,000.
However, if the house’s appraisal value is $180,000 rather than $200,000, the lender will only lend the buyer $144,000 rather than $160,000, a $16,000 difference, unless they modify their loan programs.
To make up the difference, the buyer could put down an additional $16,000, but it is more likely that they will work with the seller to reduce the price somewhat.
Should the buyer be unable to negotiate a lower price with the seller, they will need to provide a larger down payment or, if permitted by the terms of the contract, terminate it.
An additional concern that is rarely addressed in this context is how “appraisal creep” drives up house prices on its own.
These excessively high appraisals caused some homes to sell for 4% more than what they were worth, which in turn made them comps for subsequent appraisals that were even higher and so on, driving up home prices.
Furthermore, this may also affect price indices such as the Case-Shiller Home Price Index.
However, that subject will have to wait for another day because this post is already far too lengthy.
# # #
This video goes through the whole process of finding a good appraiser. Most of it applies to anyone looking for a good real estate appraiser although it’s part of a free course on how to buy the house your rent from your landlord.
FAQ
Do appraisers know the offer amount?
The appraiser will probably be aware of a home’s selling price. The appraiser will have a copy of the purchase contract because the standard appraisal forms require the appraiser to enter the information.
Does appraisal determine loan amount?
Because your lender grants you a home loan based on the appraisal’s estimate of the home’s fair market value, an appraisal has a direct impact on the amount of mortgage you’re loaned. It prevents both the lender and you from making larger loan amounts than necessary for a specific home.
Do appraisals usually match asking price?
When a seller works with a reputable real estate agent, they are more likely to set a fair price for their property. If the buyer doesn’t engage in an intense bidding war that drives up the price, the appraisal value should eventually match the sales price.
What happens if house appraises for more than purchase price?
A higher appraised value doesn’t really matter in a purchase transaction. Lenders will use the lower of the sales price or the appraised value when assessing a loan application.
Read More :
https://www.masterappraisalservices.com/do-appraisers-know-the-selling-price
Do appraisers know the purchase price?
byu/ospreyintokyo inRealEstate